"There are two Affordable Care Acts. There's the legislation passed by Congress in 2009, and then there's the mythical Affordable Care Act – the perfidious 'government takeover' decried and demagogued by so many conservatives (and quite a few liberals). The former is quite popular, the latter gets decidedly mixed reviews."
Estimated effect of the Affordable Care Act on total national health spending
"The estimated effects of the Affordable Care Act on overall national health expenditures (NHE) are shown by the 'net total' curve in the ... [above] chart. In aggregate, we estimate that for calendar years 2010 through 2019, NHE would increase by $311 billion, or 0.9 percent, compared to prior law. Year by year, the relative increases are largest in 2016, when the coverage expansions would be fully phased in (2.0 percent), and gradually decline thereafter to 1.0 percent in 2019.
The net total increase in NHE reflects several large—and largely offsetting—effects on expenditures by private health insurance, Medicare, Medicaid, and individuals’ own out-of-pocket costs, as shown by the columns in the chart above. Health expenditures are expected to increase by about $200 billion annually due to the substantial expansions of coverage under the Affordable Care Act. Numerous studies have demonstrated that individuals and families with health insurance use more health services than otherwise-similar persons without insurance. Under the health reform legislation, by 2019 an estimated 34 million currently uninsured people would gain comprehensive coverage through the health insurance Exchanges, their employers, or Medicaid. The availability of coverage would typically result in a fairly substantial increase in the utilization of health care services, with a corresponding impact on total health expenditures. These higher costs would be partially offset by the sizable discounts imposed on providers by State Medicaid payment rules and by the significant discounts negotiated by private health insurance plans. We estimate that the net effect of the utilization increases and price reductions arising from the coverage provisions of the Affordable Care Act would increase NHE in 2019 by about 3.4 percent.
The Affordable Care Act will also affect aggregate NHE through the Medicare savings provisions. We estimate that these impacts would reduce NHE by roughly 2.4 percent in 2019, assuming that the productivity adjustments to Medicare payment updates can be sustained through this period. The legislation would have only a slight impact on the utilization of health care services by Medicare beneficiaries (subject to the caveat mentioned previously regarding possible access issues if Medicare payment rates become inadequate). As shown in the chart, the Medicare savings accumulate rapidly, principally due to the compounding effect of the slower payment updates for most categories of providers.
As indicated in the chart, out-of-pocket spending would be reduced significantly by the Affordable Care Act (an estimated net total decline of $237 billion in calendar years 2010-2019). This reduction reflects the net impact of (i) the substantial coverage expansions through Medicaid and the health insurance Exchanges, (ii) the significant cost-sharing subsidies for low-to-middle-income persons with Exchange coverage, (iii) the maximum out-of-pocket limitations associated with the qualified health benefit, (iv) lower cost-sharing payments by beneficiaries in fee-for-service Medicare, (v) higher cost-sharing payments by Medicare Advantage enrollees, and (vi) the increases in workers’ cost-sharing obligations in plans affected by the excise tax on high-cost employer-sponsored health insurance coverage.
A number of the other provisions in the Affordable Care Act would also affect national health expenditures during 2010-2019, although the magnitude of these effects would be much smaller than the financial effects of the coverage expansions and Medicare savings provisions. These other provisions include the immediate insurance reforms in Title I; comparative effectiveness research; the excise tax on high-cost employer health plans; fees on health insurance plans and on manufacturers and importers of brand-name prescription drugs; and an excise tax on non-personal-use retail sales by manufacturers and importers of medical devices. The effects of these provisions are included in the respective categories of national health expenditures shown in preceding chart."
More About This Topic...
Click thumbnails below to view links
- The Estimated Effect of the Affordable Care Act on Medicare and Medicaid Outlays and Total National Health Care Expenditures
- Historical and Projected Medicaid Enrollment and Expenditures
- Net Effect of Major Legislation on Medicare Spending
- Summary of Coverage Provisions in the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act
- Number of Uninsured under PPACA
- Percent Uninsured by Age, 2008
- Obamacare (Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act)
- The List of the Obamacare Taxes
- Expected Total Gains in Life Years with an Individual Mandate