A Book to Hoard Before It Gets Cancelled

2 ¼ min

First the crazies tore down statues they deemed offensive. Next they vandalized churches. Then they demanded trigger warnings on classic movies like Gone with the Wind and Blazing Saddles. If these monsters ever discover libraries, books will be next. Let me suggest you hoard copies of William McNeill’s The Rise of the West: A History of the Human Community (1963) before they shred them. In these savages’ simple minds, McNeill’s ethnocentric title alone will justify the book’s eradication. Even Chronicles’ readers may find McNeill’s conclusions insensitive at times, as when he wrote, “The loss to human culture involved in the Spanish extirpation of Amerindian civilizations does not therefore seem very great.”

McNeill’s tour de force covers Middle Eastern predominance up to 500 B.C., then focuses on Eurasia from then to A.D. 1500, all as prelude to what he calls the “Western dominance” that followed. Despite its political incorrectness, Rise presents more than two millennia of non-Western history as the foundation of the West’s rise.

McNeill writes history the correct way, in which truth is allowed to offend insecure tribes, entrenched interests, and implacable ideologues. To cheers and jeers, he summarized the West’s increasingly global presence: “Indeed, world history since 1500 may be thought of as…the West’s growing power to molest the rest of the world.” While honest observers admit the costs of Western expansion, West-o-phobes see all Western expansion as pernicious imperialism. McNeill squares the circle with historical evidence and logical explanations.

His dispassionate take on the barbarism of history provides perspective to those of us witnessing contemporary destruction. “For all their violence and rapine, fundamentally the barbarians sought not to destroy but to enjoy the sweets of civilization,” he wrote. Sounds comforting, even if it doesn’t quite jibe with the catastrophic demands coming from Portland, Seattle, and the Democrats. Maybe yesterday’s hooligans came from a more cultured caste.

Compare last April’s ventilator shortage in New York with McNeill’s summary of ancient Greek cities whose reliance on food imports proved disastrous. “A brief interruption of supply lines could produce severe local famine,” he wrote. And, in third century Sparta where “the few tended to become richer, the rest poorer” McNeill wrote that “revolutionary demands, for the abolition of debts…were frequently heard.” It reminds one of the calls by Sen. Elizabeth Warren and others for free college tuition as recompense for income inequality.

At the University of Chicago, McNeill oversaw the dissertation of my Ph.D. advisor, Walter McDougall, making him my “doctoral grandfather.” McDougall always spoke reverentially of McNeill. Unsurprisingly, the book’s prophetic final prediction floored me: “Intimate and decisive confrontation between Chinese and Western civilizations…promises to generate the most important cultural interaction of…the twenty-first century.”

Add a Comment


Join the conversation...

You are currently using the BETA version of our article comments feature. You may notice some bugs in submission and user experience. Significant improvements are coming soon!


Account Photo
McNeill was a giant among historians of his generation. "Plagues and Peoples" is a great and sadly relevant read for our current moment. The great question of global history is "why the West." Niall Fergusson is among the most recent to try and answer. Diamond's widely praised and used "Guns, Germa, and Steel" is a prolonged rumination on why ' the white fella has so much cargo." The West and the Rest is hurtful to the woke, but the plain fact is modernity is western. Anyone engaged with the modern world is westernized as a result. The West is the Matrix and there is no red pill. If there was one, it would be made by a European or American pharma giant.


Account Photo
There is a red pill, its called plant medicines and Indigenous ways and cultural values. Everything this book presumes is what is directly causing mass extinction and climate collapse. Western dominance is a death sentence for the planet and a sick and sad way of life. But Indigenous People are still here, still living 8n right relationship to the planet and all our relations. Western society will implode based on its core principles being self destructive and ignorant.