According to Brides.com, the months from late spring to early fall are generally considered to be “wedding season.” My fellow Alcuin Fellows and I found that we each know roughly half a dozen or so couples that have gotten engaged in the past year, and have noticed the summer wedding trend.
A wedding trend that I was previously unaware of, but is growing in popularity and facing legal challenges in the UK, is that of humanist weddings. A recent article in The Guardian explained that, following a court ruling enabling soccer player Eunan O’Kane and his fiancée, model Laura Lacole, to have a humanist wedding last year, the appeals court has declined to grant legal status to humanist weddings.
Naturally, I was curious. What is a humanist wedding, and why is its legal status currently disputed?
A humanist wedding is officiated by a humanist celebrant, an individual within the humanist community who has been ordained to oversee significant life events, such as a wedding, from a humanist perspective. The ceremony usually contains religious elements, often drawing from multiple religious traditions, without any mention of God.
It turns out that the legal battle in which O’Kane and Lacole found themselves comes down to differences in marriage laws in the UK and the US. In the US, it is relatively easy to get ordained, and there are multiple online organizations that will help you get ordained with just a few clicks of the mouse. (See here, here, and here.) The legitimacy of this ordination varies from state to state, but is generally recognized as valid. Aside from a snafu over the use of a Christian chapel for a humanist wedding in 2013, humanist weddings have gone on with little controversy and little attention in the US.
In the UK, on the other hand, a wedding may either be a religious ceremony, generally performed by the Church of England, or a civil ceremony, which has no mention of religion. A humanist wedding falls into neither category.
A religious wedding in the UK typically follows one of three set scripts from the Anglican church, and a civil ceremony must be strictly non-religious. This provides little room for a customized ceremony, hence the draw of the humanist wedding. In the first ten years after their legalization in Scotland, which has slightly different marriage laws from the rest of the UK because of the separate establishment of the Church of Scotland, humanist weddings skyrocketed in popularity, outnumbering weddings in the national Church of Scotland and the Roman Catholic Church.
For the rest of the UK, the court determined that under current law couples are able to obtain temporary authorization for a humanist wedding, which is what O’Kane and Lacole did, but the appeal to change the wording of the law to include “or beliefs” where it currently only says religion was denied.
This is where we get into some of the complications of humanism. In general, humanists consider themselves as non-religious. Some groups, especially in the US, have accepted the designation “humanist religion,” but many push back on this, arguing that humanism is a secular belief system because humanists do not believe in any supernatural higher power.
Humanists UK describes a wedding as “too personal” an occasion for a set script. What I found interesting was the way that, while emphasizing a shift toward individuality, humanist weddings generally draw from traditional aspects of religious weddings. Louise Ridley, writing for the Huffington Post about her experience having a humanist wedding says, “In our case, a humanist wedding meant a tailor-made ceremony, keeping the traditions we liked and tweaking or ditching those we didn't.”
The emphasis on the individual in Western culture is certainly not limited to weddings. But the intriguing thing is, in the midst of the turn toward the individual, there also appears to be an ever-increasing desire for tradition. The rise of vintage fashion as well as the popularity of “rustic” interior design and weddings indicate an almost nostalgic yearning for the past.
For all the emphasis on individual expression, people still seem to be attracted to tradition, even ceremony and liturgy. It is interesting that with religious “nones” becoming the second largest religious group in North America and most of Europe, we are also observing the emerging popularity of humanist weddings and even an atheist church.
Perhaps the modern emphasis on individuality is revealing a desire for the connectedness and tradition that has historically been found in religion.
[Image: Flickr, CCO Creative Commons]
Patience Griswold is a 2018 Alcuin Intern with Intellectual Takeout. In her spare time, she enjoys hiking, reading, and spending time with family and friends.