Manufacturing More Mom Guilt

4 ¾ min

A little over a year ago I got a note from a reader who told me she was leaving her present job for a better one. She was climbing the ladder of success and… heading home.

That’s right, her new job was one which the corporate world might frown upon, with responsibilities including changing diapers, wiping runny noses, and making meals for her husband and two little children. Such a decision came after wrestling for many months over how to be a good employee while still being a good mom. In other words, she had a bad case of “Mom Guilt.”

Many would argue that “mom guilt” is just a thought that needs to be rooted out of female minds immediately. Sometimes I agree. Mothers place more pressure on themselves than is necessary in many areas.

But in this instance, I’m not so sure. When it comes to struggling to juggle a career and motherhood, is mom guilt actually a good thing?

Absolutely not, declares a recent Wall Street Journal article. Adapted from Joann Lublin’s forthcoming book Power Moms, the article profiles a number of female executives, showcasing the ways in which they shrug off mom guilt from holding down a high-pressure job rather than spending more time with their children.

Efficiency is key, one mom says, recommending time-saving tips ranging from faster hair-drying methods to pre-planned outfits to expedite packing for business trips. Having “me time” is another suggestion, while having kids “select the most important events” for mom to attend is another. Mary Hamilton, a managing director for a consulting firm, tries to get rid of her mom guilt by setting aside one day per year to do something special with each of her children. Jane Stevenson, another consulting executive, took that move a step further by taking a sabbatical for a whole year in order to spend time with her children, adding that “it was the best year of my life.”

In examining these women, a few threads come forth. The first is that they all seem to acknowledge mom guilt over spending so much time away from their children is very real. The second is that the mother who took the most time off to spend with her children (Stevenson) seems the happiest.

These two observations are concerning, especially since a career supposedly makes a woman feel empowered and fulfilled. Yet since greater career opportunities opened up for women over the last several decades, their happiness levels have decreased while men’s have stayed roughly stable, to the point that women are now less happy than men. The opposite was true 50 years ago. Could some of that unhappiness be related to the mom guilt mothers experience as they miss nurturing their children full-time? If so, why do we put so much pressure on women to be in the workforce?

The answer to that question seems to point back to feminist ideals. Proponents of feminism often have a two-pronged attack: 1) make women think they can have it all; and 2) degrade men.

Men were once the breadwinners of the family, be they in a high-end, white collar profession like law, or a middle-class, blue-collar job like carpentry. Yet today our culture makes it difficult for men to support a family. Women are often prioritized in hiring, as their female status meets diversity quotas, and blue-collar jobs that make a decent wage are quickly disappearing due to politically correct policies such as strict environmental standards which shut down pipelines and factories. The more difficult it is for men to hold down a good-paying job, the more difficult it is for women to believe they can ditch a major source of mom guilt by accepting the natural draw to stay home and raise their children.

This dilemma also contributes to the idea that women can have it all. Our materialistic society has convinced us that new cars, brand-name clothes, regular dinners out, and expensive vacations are all a part of the good life. When a woman’s husband cannot support such materialism on his single salary, women are convinced they must head to the workforce to pick up the slack. Add in the notion that successful women pursue college educations, even obtaining multiple degrees in the quest to break glass ceilings, and the idea of giving all that up in order to raise children makes women feel like failures.

But are women really a failure if all they do in life is stay home and raise children? Hardly. As the famous poet William Ross Wallace reminds us, “the hand that rocks the cradle is the hand that rules the world.” The poem continues:

Woman, how divine your mission,
Here upon our natal sod;
Keep—oh, keep the young heart open
Always to the breath of God!
All true trophies of the ages
Are from mother-love impearled…

In other words, the glories and rewards of motherhood extend beyond the rulership of this world and into the next. When that kind of happiness and privilege is offered to women by tending and nourishing the little plants given to us in our children, doesn’t it seem a bit foolish to make ourselves miserable with guilt while chasing after the trophies of wealth, fame, or prestige?


Dear Readers,

Big Tech is suppressing our reach, refusing to let us advertise and squelching our ability to serve up a steady diet of truth and ideas. Help us fight back by becoming a member for just $5 a month and then join the discussion on Parler @CharlemagneInstitute and Gab @CharlemagneInstitute!

Image Credit: 

Flickr-Mark Colomb, CC BY 2.0

Annie Holmquist

Annie Holmquist

Annie Holmquist is the editor of Intellectual Takeout. When not writing or editing, she enjoys reading, gardening, and time with family and friends.

Add a Comment


Join the conversation...

You are currently using the BETA version of our article comments feature. You may notice some bugs in submission and user experience. Significant improvements are coming soon!


Account Photo
I stayed home when the kids were young and I am happy I did. I do make less money now than I would have, but work is actually a breeze compared to motherhood. I found motherhood to be hard. Looking back, I think a little bit of my own life or part time career options (that were not obvious to me then) would have kept me more balanced. But, when I see mom's who spend two hours a day with their toddlers, to drop.iff and pick up mostly, I think that's also out of balance. I think flexibility and options would be nice.


Cant serve two masters. Either work thecorporate slavemarket, or stay home and raise amazing children and support your Husband to succeed "out there". The happiest and most contented moms I've known all my life have been ones who served their families. Some have even built VERY successful businesses they run from home, with the help of their children as they get old enough to do things. Double shammy: the KIDS learn things they never could in school, especiallly da gummit skewlz. I also know at least a coule dozen adults who were homeschoold by a full time Mom and are now wildly successful and wealthy, and really don't care much about the money theyhave rolling in... at least some of them in seven figure rolls. Yet they are as down to earth, regular folks, approachable, faithful friends.. something else that rarely comes out of dem gummit skewlz. Some of these men and women I've known for twentyyears or more, and they do nothing but astund me. The fifteen year old "Mole Master" now forty recently sold the business he built up fromhis dead mole earnings (in another sector) for nine million. His other siblings are doing well.. because they had a FULL TIME Mom and a very faithful and dedicated dad, as a rock solid team. Who needs the corporate ladder? Just a different flavour of slavery. They own you, until the gravy train wrecks, then you are broke.


Account Photo


Account Photo
Once I became pregnant in my early thirties, I left corporate to open my own small business. I'd work when my son napped and on weekends when his dad was home. It enabled me to keep a toehold in my industry while still devoting the bulk of my time toward tending and raising my son and managing our household. I'm proud to say that my son has benefitted enormously from my devotion. He's no snowflake. Halfway through to his master's degree in engineering and already with an offer of full-time work. He also learned how to run a small business from me and put that info to work to sell lemonaid, his old Lego pieces, and later, technical services via his own iPhone repair biz. Guess it's a matter of priorities. My only son's life was my greatest creation, and I took it very seriously.